| 1. | Joe Mauer, Twins | 21. | Benjie Molina, Giants |
| 2. | Victor Martinez, Indians | 22. | Chris Iannetta, Rockies |
| 3. | Brian McCann, Braves | 23. | Miguel Olivo, Marlins |
| 4. | Jorge Posada, Yankees | 24. | Mike Napoli, Angels |
| 5. | Ramon Hernandez, Orioles | 25. | Dioner Navarro, Devil Rays |
| 6. | Kenji Johjima, Mariners | 26. | Chris Snyder, Diamondbacks |
| 7. | Mike Piazza, A's | 27. | Yadier Molina, Cardinals |
| 8. | Ivan Rodriguez, Tigers | 28. | Rod Barajas, Phillies |
| 9. | Michael Barrett, Cubs | 29. | Jeff Mathis, Angels |
| 10. | Russell Martin, Dodgers | 30. | Brian Schneider, Nationals |
| 11. | Jason Varitek, Red Sox | 31. | Miguel Montero, D Backs |
| 12. | A.J. Pierzynski, White Sox | 32. | Javier Valentin, Reds |
| 13. | Paul LoDuca, Mets | 33. | Carlos Ruiz, Phillies |
| 14. | David Ross, Reds | 34. | Javy Lopez, Rockies |
| 15. | Josh Bard, Padres | 35. | John Buck, Royals |
| 16. | Jason Kendall, A's | 36. | Jason LaRue, Royals |
| 17. | Johnny Estrada, Brewers | 37. | Eliezer Alfonzo, Giants |
| 18. | Gerald Laird, Rangers | 38. | Mike Lieberthal, Dodgers |
| 19. | Gregg Zaun, Blue Jays | 39. | Toby Hall, White Sox |
| 20. | Ronny Paulino, Pirates | 40. | Chris Coste, Phillies |
